Water Buffalo 9" Retriever Style Cheek Roll Dog Chews-3 Pack (Long Lasting Dog Chews, Treats, Bones for for Large Dogs) Substitute for Pig Ears for Dogs

This is the longest lasting treat I have given my tough chewers! It doesn't smell the best but what do you expect from real buffalo cheek roll... mine have never smelled as bad as some of these reviews. I think people are being very dramatic..I don't care about it being a tab smelly. I care about the fact it is digestive and safe for my dogs to eat. AND it last at least an hour for my babies so they love them!Happy with this product and will be purchasing more!

I ordered enough for 5 medium-large breed dogs (WSS, lab, Dutch shepherd, and two German shepherds). All of them absolutely loved them. I looked into the beef cheek rolls when a friend of mine told me about them. I'm hesitant with raw hides; raw marrow bones are expensive; nyla bones, or anything of the like are out as well; and I can't give my dogs hard bones because they'll break a tooth. I bought the 9'' rolls, and I am impressed at how long they've lasted. Now, I do pay attention to how long my dogs have them. I'm not just giving them the rolls and then forgetting about them. Plus, I've been checking in with teeth, and am very happy at how clean the rolls help them get.I will say that the WSS, lab, and Dutchie have shown to get a small bit of upset stomach (loose poops and MAYBE diarrhea), but it only last for a day, at most. AND, the dutchie tends to have the most sensitive stomach, so soft poops and diarrhea are an on-going thing for him. But I agree with someone else's review that if your dogs don't have a strong stomach, then be prepared for some upset tummies. Definitely will continue to purchase these.

These last my b heelers at least 2 hours.They love them and will chew on them for hours. And tend to pause in between chewing to take naps.These bones a have a little smell to the but nothing compared to hooves and other bones I’ve bought before. Just wish they had a bigger bag and cheaper price.

These are amazing for my pitbull who choose bones like crazy. They smell like most other cheek rolls, which isn't pleasant, but I already knew that when buying them. They're alo a bit pricey. But the longevity of these bones makes it worth purchasing.

I have a 3yr old 20lb terrier mix. He chews to eat. He has been going at 1 chew for the last 4 days and is barely making a difference. He chews on it for about an hour or two total a day. Definitely worth it.

My dogs loved this but they can definitely swallow big pieces and that’s a huge risk for an emergency surgery I don’t wanna pay for.

So many chews say they are long lasting, but one of my 11 mo. old labs is a serious chewer and can make that claim seem ridiculous. So, I bought these hoping for the best but not getting too excited. The smell attracted the dogs at first. Then, surprise, my chew monster fell asleep half way through his roll. He was exhausted and had a piece sticking out of his mouth as he just rolled to his side and closed his eyes. I will be buying this again!!!

[PLEASE SEE UPDATE AT THE BOTTOM]I paid $22 for a 3 pack of nine inch wrapped rolls. I have three dogs. It just got here and has one roll in it. Just one roll. And my options are I return it and have it replaced or I can return it and get a refund. I don’t want to take the time out of my day to take this incorrect order to the UPS to have it returned. I want to be shipped the three pack I paid $22 for. I was excited to have my dogs try these because the reviews seem high and I may have become a regular customer, but I feel like I just got ripped off. It’s a shame because it seems like a great product.UPDATE: I was very quickly contacted by Selena from their customer service team, and she ensured I was sent a free replacement, and it was shipped in a timely manner. My dogs all very much enjoyed these treats and they lasted about 2 or 3 hours. The treats are kind of stinky but only when you have them in your hand. Very satisfied with the customer service I received and updated my review from 1 star to 4 stars.